Human Consensus In Cryptocurrency Networks
How Bitcoin coordinates work amongst disparate groups of human volunteers
So far we have argued that free open source software is the right medium for digital infrastructure, because its processes discourage spurious, ceremonial, expensive, and monotechnic developments. This is accomplished through tried-and-true software-making practices developed by hackers over the last 30 years.
In this section, we will discuss how Satoshi Nakamoto innovated on top of existing open allocation governance processes in order to make them robust enough to govern a currency system.
The fundamental challenge of any social system is that people are inclined to break the rules when it’s profitable and expedient. Unlike present-day financial systems, which are hemmed in by laws and conventions, the Bitcoin system formalizes human rules into a software network. But how does the system prevent human engineers from changing this system over time to benefit themselves?
Nakamoto’s solution to this question can be broken down into three parts:
Make all participants “administrators” of the system, with no central controller.
Require most or many participants to agree to any necessary rule changes.
Make colluding to change the rules extremely expensive to attempt.
These solutions are nice in theory, but it’s important to remember that Nakamoto sought to enforce these rules upon human participants by using a software system. Prior to the release of Bitcoin, doing so would have run up against two specific unsolved engineering challenges:
How can a system with many different computers maintain a database of transactions, without the use of a central coordinating computer? (In such a system, anyone with access to the central coordinating computer could change the rules in the system for their own benefit.)
How do all the different administrators agree that the database was not, in fact, altered? (In a system where past transactions can be changed, rules about transaction processing are rendered irrelevant.)
To answer these questions, we need to explore how humans and machines in a network reach agreement on common rules and history. This section will focus on how human beings organize within the system into three distinct roles; the next section will focus on the use of a network of machines to enforce the rules and behavior of the participants.
Pioneering work that led to Bitcoin
A financial system with the aforementioned attributes is not a new concept. Ever since Tim May had proposed “crypto anarchy” in 1992, the cypherpunks had been trying to realize their digital currency systems as a way of creating a private, pseudonymous micro-economy that would be resistant to cheating or counterfeiting—even without anyone policing the participants.
Bitcoin was not the first attempt at digital money. Indeed, the idea was pioneered by David Chaum in 1983. In Chaum’s model, a central server prevented double-spending, but this was problematic:
“The requirement for a central server became the Achilles’ heel of digital cash. While it is possible to distribute this single point of failure by replacing the central server’s signature with a threshold signature of several signers, it is important for auditability that the signers be distinct 10 and identifiable. This still leaves the system vulnerable to failure, since each signer can fail, or be made to fail, one by one.”
Digicash was another example of a currency that failed due to regulatory requirements placed on its central authority; it was clear that the necessity to police the owners of the system significantly undermined the efficiencies gained by the digitization of a currency system.
Cypherpunk Wei Dei was directly influenced by crypto-anarchy when he came up with his decentralized “B-money” proposal in 1998. “I am fascinated by Tim May's cryptoanarchy,” he writes in the introduction to his essay:
“Unlike the communities traditionally associated with the word ‘anarchy,’ in a crypto-anarchy the government is not temporarily destroyed but permanently forbidden and permanently unnecessary. It's a community where the threat of violence is impotent because violence is impossible, and violence is impossible because its participants cannot be linked to their true names or physical locations.”
Dai’s concept was based on recent developments in computer science which suggested that such a system might be feasible.
Prior art
As of the early 2000s, recent innovations had made Wei Dai’s B-money concept possible. Scott Stornetta and Stuart Haber had proposed something called “linked timestamping” in 1990 to build a trusted chain of digital signatures which could be used to notarize and timestamp a document, preventing retroactive tampering. In 1997, Adam Back invented Hashcash, a denial of service protection for P2P networks, which would make it expensive and difficult for participants to collude to alter past transactions.
Still, participants might collude to break the rules in other ways, such as to counterfeit coins. Hal Finney proposed the use of “reusable PoW,” in which the code for “minting” coins is published on a secure centralized computer, and users can use remote attestation to prove the computing cycles actually executed. In 2005, Nick Szabo suggested using a “distributed title registry” instead of a secure centralized computer.
In early 2009, Satoshi Nakamoto released the first implementation of a peer-to-peer electronic cash system, wherein the central server’s signature of authority was replaced by a decentralized “Proof-of-Work” system. Nakamoto wrote after launch that “Bitcoin is an implementation of Wei Dai's b-money proposal on Cypherpunks in 1998, and Nick Szabo's Bitgold proposal.”
These foundational ideas cited by Nakamoto may have drawn on contemporary economic concepts about currency markets. In a lecture delivered at the Gold and Monetary Conference, in New Orleans in 1977, economist Friedrich Hayek said:
“The monopoly of government of issuing money has not only deprived us of good money but has also deprived us of the only process by which we can find out what would be good money. We do not even quite know what exact qualities we want, because in the two thousand years in which we have used coins and other money, we have never been allowed to experiment with it, we have never been given a chance to find out what the best kind of money would be.”
This comment from 1984 is also widely attributed to Hayek:
“I don’t believe we shall ever have a good money again before we take the thing out of the hands of government. We can’t take it violently out of the hands of government, all we can do is by some sly roundabout way introduce something that they can’t stop.”
How Bitcoin works, briefly
Well-written tutorials about “how Bitcoin works” are plentiful. Instead of reproducing those explanations, the following paragraphs explain only what is required to understand the design rationale of the system, as a way of elucidating its purpose. Specifically, we will explore the incentive system, which keeps Bitcoin’s contributors working together in lieu of any formal association.
Central to the Bitcoin system is the concept of “mining,” which will be explained in greater depth in the next section. For now, mining can be understood as the process by which blocks of transactions are processed and added to Bitcoin’s ledger, also known as “the blockchain.” “Transactions” can be understood to mean people sending bitcoins to each other; there’s also a transaction that pays miners for processing blocks. The reconciliation and settlement of transactions in Bitcoin happens by a different process than in conventional payments systems.
How users agree on which network is “Bitcoin”
Many users only experience Bitcoin transactions through a lightweight “wallet” application on a mobile phone. Wallet applications are user friendly, and conceal much of the complexity of the underlying network. The primary feature of a wallet application is the ability to send and receive transactions. Secondarily, the application will show you a transaction history, and a current balance of bitcoins in your possession. This information is taken directly from the network itself, which has the ability to remember preceding transactions, a stateful computing system.
Bitcoin is not exactly stateful the way your smartphone or computer is. It calculates and recalculates the every balance every 10 minutes, all in one go, like a mechanized spreadsheet. It can be said that Bitcoin is a single computer comprised of many individual pieces of hardware, or virtual machine, distributed across the globe, working together towards that recurring 10-minute rebalancing of the ledger.
These machines can be sure they are connecting to the same network because they are using a network protocol, or a set of machine instructions built into the Bitcoin software. It is often said that Bitcoin is “not connected to the World Wide Web,” because it does not communicate using the HTTP protocol like Web browsers do.
While it’s true that Bitcoin is not a “Web application” like Facebook or Twitter, it does use the same underlying Internet infrastructure as the Web. The “Internet protocol suite” emerged as a DARPA-funded project at Stanford University between 1973 and 1974. It was made a military standard by the US Department of Defense in 1982, and corporations like AT%story%T and IBM began using it in 1984
In the application layer, third-party processes can create user data and send this data to other applications, which live on the same or different hosts. The application layer makes use of the services of the underlying layers.
Within this application layer exists not just the World Wide Web, but also the SMTP email protocol, FTP for file transfer, SSH for secure direct connections to other machines, and various others—including Bitcoin and other cryptocurrency networks. We’ve said that free software like Bitcoin can be copied and re-deployed by anyone, so how can disparate versions not interfere?
In practice, they do, to some extent. The Bitcoin software will automatically try to connect to the Bitcoin blockchain, but changing configuration files and modifying the Bitcoin software may allow you to connect to another Bitcoin-like network people have created from what is known as a Bitcoin fork. Some of these forks may have Bitcoin-like names, and claim to improve upon Bitcoin, but few of these forks will be valued by the market; altcoins will be discussed at greater length in Section VII.
With a traditional debit or credit card, any financial activity you conduct over the Internet is recorded within your “account,” stored on the card issuer’s central computer or cloud. There are no accounts in Bitcoin. Instead, funds (ie., bitcoins) are controlled by a pair of cryptographic keys. Any person can generate a pair of keys using a Bitcoin wallet, and no personal information is required. Individuals can hold as many keypairs as they like, and groups of people can share access to funds with “multi-signature” wallets.
As we will see, wallet-users are just one group of stakeholders in the Bitcoin network. Software for technical users also exists in several forms; it can be downloaded directly from the Bitcoin code repository, from your Terminal (in macOS or Linux).
Users who run and store the full transaction history of the network on their computer will see it occupy about 200GB. Running a copy of the Bitcoin software and storing the whole blockchain is known as running a full node. As we’ll see, full node operators are very important to the Bitcoin network, even though they are not “mining” blocks.
Once the Bitcoin software is installed on your Internet-connected phone or computer, you can send and receive Bitcoin transactions to anyone else in the world, for any arbitrary quantity. Sending Bitcoins incurs a small fee, which is paid to miners.
Next, we’ll discuss what happens when a user sends a transaction to the Bitcoin network.
How the system knows who is who
Sending transactions on the Bitcoin network modifies the state of the ledger, the blockchain. In order to hold Bitcoin and make transactions, the user must first generate a pair of cryptographic keys, also known as a keypair. Keys are used to digitally sign data without encrypting it.
A transaction is recorded in the blockchain’s state transition if it meets several criteria: a valid digital signature must be present for the Bitcoins being spent, and the keypair must control a sufficient balance of bitcoins to pay the transaction.
General ledgers have been in use in accounting for 1,000 years, and many good primers exist on double-entry accounting and ledger-balancing. Bitcoin can be thought of as “triple-entry” accounting: both counterparties in a given transaction have a record of it in their ledger, and the network also has a copy of everyone’s transactions. This comprehensive history of every Bitcoin transaction ever is stored redundantly on every single full node. This is the 200GB of data you download when you store the blockchain.
Bitcoin’s addresses are an example of public key cryptography, where one key is held private and one is used as a public identifier. This is also known as asymmetric cryptography, because the two keys in the “pair” serve different functions. In Bitcoin, keypairs are derived using the ECDSA algorithm.
bitcoin ne
bitcoin base bitcoin antminer future bitcoin торрент bitcoin buy ethereum cons of entering the market with dollar-cost averaging, lump-sum investing,сборщик bitcoin bitcoin china продать monero
Denominationsbitcointalk bitcoin bitcoin чат course bitcoin bitcoin сбор ethereum прогнозы daemon monero
flash bitcoin bitcoin краны сбербанк bitcoin miningpoolhub monero bitcoin boom bitcoin greenaddress bitcoin xl cubits bitcoin bitcoin tube bitcoin stock bitcoin store online bitcoin analysis bitcoin ethereum курс gas ethereum bitcoin майнить bitcoin 3 дешевеет bitcoin bitcoin php statistics bitcoin georgia bitcoin foto bitcoin byzantium ethereum bitcoin grant monster bitcoin bitcoin отзывы There are several ways to mine Monero, but before we get into that, you need to know what a Monero mining pool is.Touted mitigations to state censorship of Bitcoin’s broadcast layer include Nick Szabo’s long-range radio proposal as well as Samourai/Gotenna’s SMS and short-range radio mesh proofs of concept. These initiatives, however, are still either in the R%trump2%D phase or the very earliest phases of deployment. At present, individuals in internet-restricted locations have little recourse when faced with such an attack, aside from physically getting their funds out of the country in a hardware or paper wallet. This doesn’t, in my opinion, represent a threat to the network itself: it would take an unbelievable amount of international cooperation among states to regulate Bitcoin in this manner.вход bitcoin ethereum complexity bitcoin xt bitcoin elena bitcoin paw mine monero 10000 bitcoin дешевеет bitcoin ethereum nicehash bitcoin protocol ethereum coingecko автомат bitcoin bitcoin tools asics bitcoin nova bitcoin monero bitcointalk bitcoin aliexpress картинки bitcoin платформы ethereum продам bitcoin bitcoin пожертвование payeer bitcoin конвектор bitcoin bitcoin спекуляция bitcoin лохотрон monero обменять microsoft bitcoin играть bitcoin bitcoin legal сервисы bitcoin roulette bitcoin cryptocurrency trading korbit bitcoin bitcoin видео cryptocurrency mining кости bitcoin ethereum transactions кости bitcoin express bitcoin future bitcoin cryptocurrency wallet bitcoin mining
ethereum сегодня bitcoin motherboard bitcoin ads bitcoin bio краны monero icon bitcoin monero address magic bitcoin tcc bitcoin monero hashrate кликер bitcoin 0 bitcoin bitcoin сегодня bitcoin rub
bitcoin код
bitcoin exe bitcoin кранов locate bitcoin bitcoin global
registration bitcoin rx470 monero bitcoin tools
wordpress bitcoin карты bitcoin эфириум ethereum cryptocurrency calendar primedice bitcoin bitcoin joker invest bitcoin tether usd abc bitcoin instaforex bitcoin agario bitcoin In early May 2020, Paul Tudor Jones became publicly bullish and went long Bitcoin, describing it as a hedge against money-printing and inflation. He drew comparisons between Bitcoin in the 2020’s and gold in the early 1970’s.bitcoin банк On 13/06/11 12:56 PM, James A. Donald wrote:china bitcoin
bitcoin мастернода secp256k1 bitcoin сбербанк ethereum rush bitcoin ethereum casino bitcoin бизнес команды bitcoin service bitcoin займ bitcoin bitcoin вложения скачать bitcoin converter bitcoin top cryptocurrency ethereum биткоин platinum bitcoin
change bitcoin bitcoin rub
bitcoin services clame bitcoin bitcoin комбайн майн bitcoin bitcoin tor bitcoin pizza
конвертер ethereum ethereum бесплатно ethereum rotator bistler bitcoin clame bitcoin bitcoin tools tether верификация bitcoin миллионеры новый bitcoin favicon bitcoin boom bitcoin
bitcoin оборот cronox bitcoin coin bitcoin порт bitcoin happy bitcoin bitcoin 2 monero стоимость трейдинг bitcoin bitcoin pps captcha bitcoin эмиссия ethereum tether майнинг принимаем bitcoin monero dwarfpool bitcoin кэш 1080 ethereum wikileaks bitcoin main bitcoin запрет bitcoin
торги bitcoin bitcoin asics контракты ethereum bitcoin конвектор будущее ethereum 1000 bitcoin gold cryptocurrency bitcoin win bitcoin koshelek bitcoin продать phoenix bitcoin
monero proxy bitcoin registration е bitcoin bounty bitcoin txid bitcoin ethereum btc bitcoin картинки konvert bitcoin торги bitcoin
шахта bitcoin зарегистрировать bitcoin отзыв bitcoin bitcoin scripting tether gps ethereum gold bitcoin иконка bitcoin mining ethereum russia earn bitcoin
криптовалюту monero bitcoin apple bitcoin иконка ethereum видеокарты tether программа avalon bitcoin wifi tether daemon monero
bitcoin market monero краны е bitcoin us bitcoin
криптокошельки ethereum bitcoin algorithm bitcoin plus платформа ethereum bitcoin авито wiki bitcoin 5 bitcoin
monero usd tether mining
ротатор bitcoin bitcoin спекуляция bitcoin аналитика chvrches tether кошелек ethereum bitcoin register ethereum torrent ethereum serpent bitcoin spinner ethereum pool utxo bitcoin зарегистрироваться bitcoin Blockchain records all the transactions in a public ledger which is globally accessible by bitcoin usersbitcoin calc порт bitcoin
bitcoin golden bitcoin stiller сервера bitcoin blocks bitcoin bitcoin qiwi usdt tether bitcoin foto обмена bitcoin bitcoin cz bitcoin компания miningpoolhub monero bitcoin форум bitcoin collector bitcoin valet bitcoin gold arbitrage cryptocurrency ethereum install получение bitcoin bitcoin казахстан bitcoin сбербанк bitcoin рулетка заработай bitcoin bitcoin club ethereum chart monero hashrate bitcoin instaforex сложность monero настройка ethereum ethereum studio зарабатывать bitcoin bitcoin fork keystore ethereum
bitcoin redex hd7850 monero bitcoin sweeper ethereum акции проекта ethereum
bitcoin будущее андроид bitcoin bitcoin проверить ethereum asics pool monero blue bitcoin bitcoin make ethereum 1070 delphi bitcoin box bitcoin bitcoin bitrix bitcoin cap gift bitcoin заработок bitcoin chart bitcoin Zooko Wilcox-O’Hearn: DigiCash developer, Founder of Zcashbitcoin kran
By WILL KENTONbitcoin китай блокчейн bitcoin bitcoin реклама roboforex bitcoin in bitcoin bitcoin database отзыв bitcoin ethereum статистика bitcoin автосерфинг bitcoin основы ethereum torrent bitcoin mercado bitcoin nedir
удвоить bitcoin ethereum обменники приложения bitcoin
bitcoin клиент monero gpu zcash bitcoin bitcoin gold bitcoin wm ethereum форум block bitcoin ubuntu ethereum tether download bitcoin blockchain bitcoin blockchain майнеры monero пулы bitcoin bitcoin conference antminer bitcoin
tor bitcoin monero nicehash bitcoin робот ethereum заработать What is a cryptocurrency: the Ethereum platform.When it went live in 2009, Bitcoin was worth zero dollars and zero cents. In April 2011, you could get 1 Bitcoin for $1. On December 17, 2017, Bitcoin had its best day so far. You could trade 1BTC for $20,052! Today, on August 7, 2021, you can trade 1BTC for $11,822. Not bad, right?bitcoin anonymous tails bitcoin стоимость ethereum wallets cryptocurrency bitcoin рулетка bitcoin brokers компьютер bitcoin Pool NamePool FeeMinimum PayoutPool AddressPool Sizeбаланс bitcoin programming bitcoin Ethereum developers actively work on their blockchain’s scalability problem. Vitalik Buterin, the co-Founder of Ethereum, believes that his blockchain could reach 1,000,000 transactions per second someday.bitcoin команды bitcoin мошенничество ethereum twitter solo bitcoin monero amd bank cryptocurrency instant bitcoin finney ethereum bitcoin advcash people bitcoin bitcoin смесители rocket bitcoin
monero биржи bitcoin bank buying bitcoin пул bitcoin x2 bitcoin mac bitcoin bitcoin авито
love bitcoin
генератор bitcoin ethereum алгоритм ethereum заработок
bitcoin converter ethereum wallet bitcoin мастернода ютуб bitcoin ethereum game
hardware bitcoin пулы monero bitcoin обменник
конец bitcoin bitcoin вебмани bitcoin evolution ethereum programming
ethereum testnet bitcoin проект mine monero connect bitcoin bitcoin statistics film bitcoin кошелька ethereum обмен tether китай bitcoin
blogspot bitcoin вывод ethereum bistler bitcoin is bitcoin bitcoin вирус excel bitcoin bitcoin количество The HMRC does not classify cryptocurrency splits as taxation events. According to HMRC, 'The value of the new cryptoassets is derived from the original cryptoassets already held by the individual.' In relation to the cost base, HMRC says that 'Costs must be split on a just and reasonable basis under section 52(4) Taxation of Capital Gains Act 1992. HMRC does not prescribe any particular apportionment method. HMRC has the power to enquire into an apportionment method that it believes is not just and reasonable.'plus500 bitcoin bitcoin habrahabr abi ethereum bitcoin school
bitcoin grant ферма ethereum bitcoin clicks alpha bitcoin analysis bitcoin stake bitcoin captcha bitcoin vip bitcoin bitcoin завести conference bitcoin tether перевод протокол bitcoin bitcoin вклады microsoft bitcoin
forecast bitcoin фермы bitcoin
bitcoin бот bitcoin заработок bitcoin birds monero address python bitcoin пополнить bitcoin nodes bitcoin rbc bitcoin tether coin bitcoin prosto bitcoin today buy tether The dichotomy between quantitative easing that central banks around the world are doing, and the quantitative tightening that Bitcoin just experienced with its third halving, makes for a great snapshot of the difference between scarcity or the lack thereof. Dollars, euro, yen, and other fiat currencies are in limitless abundance and their supply is growing quickly, while things like gold and silver and Bitcoin are inherently scarce.bitcoin лохотрон банк bitcoin
bitcoin wmx bitcoin кошелька foto bitcoin bitcoin yandex wirex bitcoin
bitcoin trend Accuracy and TransparencyWhat Is Cold Storage For Bitcoin?ethereum shares bitcoin онлайн bitcoin chains bitcoin банкнота конвектор bitcoin
bitcoin gold cryptocurrency nicehash bitcoin bitcoin монета bitcoin hype bitcoin virus wmz bitcoin nvidia monero bitcoin сайты bitcoin сигналы bitcoin king bitcoin проверить invest bitcoin новые bitcoin bitcoin cli monero новости bitcoin вклады
new cryptocurrency иконка bitcoin
автоматический bitcoin
bitcoin brokers register bitcoin bitcoin joker monero usd ethereum доходность bitcoin сети клиент bitcoin пример bitcoin bitcoin xyz p2p bitcoin bitcoin x2 Blockchain explained: Bitcoins on a computer chip.bitcoin cap котировки bitcoin bitcoin установка скрипт bitcoin solo bitcoin bitcoin registration cryptocurrency market tether usdt bitcoin обозреватель динамика bitcoin bitcoin торговля games bitcoin bitcoin banks bitcoin box bcc bitcoin
bitcoin microsoft tether 2 tether верификация bitcoin blue продать ethereum кошельки ethereum cfd bitcoin bitcoin расчет bitcoin knots прогнозы ethereum полевые bitcoin importprivkey bitcoin bitcoin trading
future bitcoin clockworkmod tether cryptocurrency dash bitcoin expanse карты bitcoin monero fr ethereum вики Of the ether that does exist, 60 million was purchased by users in a 2014 crowdfunding campaign.bitcoin ключи bitcoin telegram Nobel laureate Richard Thaler emphasizes the irrationality in the bitcoin market that has led to the bubble, demonstrating the irrationality with the example of firms that have added the word blockchain to their names which have then had large increases in their stock price. The extremely high volatility in bitcoin's price also is due to irrationality according to Thaler.ethereum coin цены bitcoin ethereum валюта bitcoin office monero gpu
bitcoin expanse bitcoin hash
bitcoin lucky today, with digital currencies such as Bitcoin playing a significant role.bitcoin hunter bitcoin legal bitcoin автоматически bitcoin мошенники
bitcoin 10000 make bitcoin bitcoin linux secp256k1 bitcoin bitcoin подтверждение block ethereum Whether PoW systems can actually solve a particular denial-of-service issue such as the spam problem is subject to debate; the system must make sending spam emails obtrusively unproductive for the spammer, but should also not prevent legitimate users from sending their messages. In other words, a genuine user should not encounter any difficulties when sending an email, but an email spammer would have to expend a considerable amount of computing power to send out many emails at once. Proof-of-work systems are being used as a primitive by other more complex cryptographic systems such as bitcoin which uses a system similar to Hashcash.Put simply, cryptocurrency custody solutions are third party providers of storage and security services for cryptocurrencies. Their services are mainly aimed at institutional investors, such as hedge funds, who hold large amounts of bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies. The solutions generally incorporate a combination of hot storage, or crypto custody with connection to the Internet, and cold storage, or crypto custody that is disconnected from the Internet. M3 (which includes all the other buckets) minus M1 is worth about 45 trillion U.S. dollars.20 We will include this as a store of value that is comparable to bitcoin. To this, we will also add an estimate for the worldwide value of gold held as a store of value. While some may use jewelry as a store of value, for our model we will only consider gold bullion. The U.S. Geological Survey estimated that at the end of 1999, there were about 122,000 metric tons of available above-ground gold.21 Of this, 48%, or 58,560 metric tons, was in the form of private and official bullion stocks. At an estimated current price of $1,200 per troy ounce, that amount of gold is today worth upwards of 2.1 trillion U.S. dollars. Since there has in recent years been a deficit in the supply of silver and governments have been selling significant amounts of their silver bullion, we reason that most silver is being used in industry and not as a store of value, and will not include silver in our model.22 Neither will we treat other precious metals or gemstones. In aggregate, our estimate for the global value of stores of value comparable to bitcoin, including savings accounts, small and large time deposits, money market funds, and gold bullion, come to 47.1 trillion U.S. dollars.delphi bitcoin bitcoin conference