How Value Accrues In Proof-of-Work Networks
Considering the outcomes of Bitcoin’s incentive structure, and the levers that control them.
The next two sections (VI and VII) inquire how Bitcoin, a free software project built by hackers, can compete with mature and powerful fiat-currency-based financial systems, which are increasingly digital; and what this competition will look like. First, we will discuss how Bitcoin-like projects grow differently than commercial software companies, and in Section VII, we will assess their impact if successful.
What qualities cause cryptocurrency systems to grow in value?
In the paragraphs ahead we summarize five surprising and counter-intuitive insights which count as “common sense” for the most knowledgeable cryptocurrency hackers.
We have established that free, open source software, built in New Jersey style, has rapidly outstripped commercial competitors at the foundations of the Web. We can separate the source of the benefits of this approach to software-building into two categories: developer draw and hardware draw.
1. Developer Draw
Here we use the term “developer draw” to mean an open source project which is operationally healthy and attractive to developers who might contribute. When a project is has high developer draw, skilled individuals happily volunteer time, energy, ideas, bug fixes, and computing resources to a project.
Satoshi Nakamoto envisioned Bitcoin as a platform for private economic activity, maintained by loose groups of volunteers. Platforms are most useful when they are stable. Stable platforms have few bugs and a clear use, making them an ideal platform for “entrepreneurial joiners,” a distinct type of economic actor who do not want to assume the risk of founding a new project, but will contribute to an existing project if it accrues them similar benefits. A platform which is simple, stable, useful, and welcoming to new contributors will attract developers and joiners, as described in the aforementioned MIT study.
Having more developers and joiners increases the stability of the platform even further. The thesis that "given enough eyeballs, all bugs are shallow,” is known as Linus's Law after the creator of Linux. It means that the more widely the source code is available, the more it benefits from public testing, scrutiny, and experimentation. These activities result in stable software.
In a private company building proprietary code, the momentous task of debugging falls on the few developers that have access to the codebase. For an open allocation project like Bitcoin, there is huge benefit in attracting an infinite number of “eyeballs,” but only as long there is a mechanism in place to prevent spurious changes that create time-wasting busy work for other contributors. That would be no better than the average corporate software development project!
Bitcoin’s incentive system allows the best of both worlds. Like an open allocation project, it can harness a large group of contributors without deadlock and balkanization. Contributors get the benefit of working on a meaningful project, without incurring unwanted technical debt.
Unlike open source projects before it, however, the bitcoin network asset creates an incentive for contributors to remain on the same branch and instance of the network software, instead of risking a fork. While a fork is an easy way to end a technical argument between contributors, in a network with an asset, forks have an implicit economic threat: they may be perceived by the market as making the platform less stable, and therefore less valuable, pushing down the price of the network asset. Like a commercial company, Bitcoin’s organizational structure incentivizes contributors to work out their differences and keep the group intact, for everyone’s financial gain.
Thus, Bitcoin is the first free, non-commercial software project with the intensity of a commercial product. Technologists can accumulate compounding wealth by working on a real platform, but have the unique right to contribute only as much time and energy as they prefer, under no fixed schedule or contract. Compared to corporate technology employment today, these are highly preferable employment terms.
2. Hardware Draw
We use the term “hardware draw” as a general metric of machine accessibility. Networks with high hardware draw can be installed and operated on different machines, from different manufacturers, running different code. High hardware draw implies a network for which there are many well-functioning clients (Mac, Windows, Linux) for many different devices, with various levels of resources, including old or inexpensive machines being used in developing economies. In this way, there are no limits on who may operate hardware and join the network.
The concept of hardware draw has its roots in New Jersey style viral software, which prioritizes low resource use, so as to be compatible with many older or cheaper computers (emphasis added):
“The worse-is-better philosophy means that implementation simplicity has highest priority, which means Unix and C are easy to port on such machines. Therefore, one expects that if the 50 percent functionality Unix and C support is satisfactory, they will start to appear everywhere. And they have, haven't they? Unix and C are the ultimate computer viruses.”
In Bitcoin, transactions contain small amounts of data, and its blockchain grows slowly. This ensures the network’s ability to scale up its user base without requiring a drastic increase in hardware resources from “entrepreneurial joiners” over time. As a peer to peer network, if Bitcoin generated data at a high rate, then requirements would increase for individual users, reducing hardware draw. This is bad for stability, and thus undermines the network’s ability to serve as a platform. Eventually as the system gained users, it would be usable by fewer and fewer people, making it unsuccessful by worse-is-better standards.
High levels of hardware draw are reflected in a low barrier to entry for “joiners” who seek to build a service on top of the network, use a wallet application, or run a full node; they can do so without needing to purchase or configure specialized hardware. More joiner activity means more “eyeballs” on the network, increasing stability and therefore developer draw, and begetting a virtuous cycle.
Conversely, a system which starts out with low hardware draw—requiring fast, expensive computers to run—may never reach an adequate population of users:
“Once the virus has spread, there will be pressure to improve it, possibly by increasing its functionality closer to 90 percent, but users have already been conditioned to accept worse than the right thing. Therefore, the worse-is-better software first will gain acceptance, second will condition its users to expect less, and third will be improved to a point that is almost the right thing.”
Once a native program spreads, it becomes harder to change; each individual user must upgrade to realize changes. Furthermore, an over-reliance on upgrading the software later will result in technical debt, as some users fail to upgrade, and developers feel pressure to continue to support these old versions of the software.
Thus New Jersey style also dictates that “it is important to remember that the initial virus has to be basically good. If so, the viral spread is assured as long as it is portable.“ Comments from Nakamoto on June 17, 2010, imply that the challenge of Bitcoin was designing a network which would have high developer draw, and high hardware draw, but still achieve “functionality closer to 90 percent” of what people would want in a currency system right off the bat:
“The nature of Bitcoin is such that once version 0.1 was released, the core design was set in stone for the rest of its lifetime. Because of that, I wanted to design it to support every possible transaction type I could think of. The problem was, each thing required special support code and data fields whether it was used or not, and only covered one special case at a time. It would have been an explosion of special cases. The solution was script, which generalizes the problem so transacting parties can describe their transaction as a predicate that the node network evaluates. The nodes only need to understand the transaction to the extent of evaluating whether the sender's conditions are met... Future versions can add templates for more transaction types and nodes running that version or higher will be able to receive them... The design supports a tremendous variety of possible transaction types that I designed years ago. Escrow transactions, bonded contracts, third party arbitration, multi-party signature, etc. If Bitcoin catches on in a big way, these are things we'll want to explore in the future, but they all had to be designed at the beginning to make sure they would be possible later.”
This uncompromising (but somewhat extensible) design rationale makes Bitcoin viral and also useful to a broad base of potential users.
Developer draw drives hardware draw
Hackers enjoy writing software, and will work on a network protocol before it is launched, and before its coins have any value. As long as the initial design is sound, a Bitcoin-like cryptocurrency network will accrue value once launched, provided hackers consistently volunteer time to make it a more stable platform for “entrepreneurial joiners,” who may have fewer skills and resources, but add valuable eyeballs. Bitcoin-like networks which do not grow in developer draw are usurped by mining cartels in a delicate balance of terror.
This means that in projects where developer draw is high, diverse contributors improve the underlying system, building and testing client applications on a broad base of hardware and software platforms. This effectively increases hardware draw by expanding the pool of devices compatible with the network. Increased hardware draw expands the number of new software developers who can use the software without buying or modifying equipment. This virtuous cycle begins with developer draw.
Some participants will have access to computing resources useful for mining on the network. Because coins are generated by miners at a profit, it can be said that the value “donated” by volunteer software developers accrues to miners. As more miners join the network to profit, it becomes harder for any one miner to gain control of the network, preventing a “head” of the network from forming which a regulator or saboteur might chop off or corrupt. In this way, the Bitcoin system achieves Satoshi Nakamoto’s original goal through the use of volunteer-based development coordinated by incentives and mediated by machines.
The enrichment of miners is a trade-off which is acceptable to the contributors only when they enjoy the contribution. If contributions are difficult or unpleasant, developer draw drops. Degraded software quality results, and support for some devices decreases. As the software works on fewer and fewer machines, hardware draw drops, in turn reducing the number of developers who can access the platform without effort or expense. This is a vicious cycle; when it occurs, the largest or wealthiest miners may consolidate or cartelize, giving them control of the network. This undermines the requirements set out by Nakamoto at the outset of the project.
Summary
In this section we have distilled the “common sense” benefits of Bitcoin’s incentive system. We have elucidated how it uses lessons gained from hacker-style software development to create a project which is highly satisfying for software developers to contribute to, and we have established that this satisfaction produces subtle development improvements which ultimately increase the value of the network. In the next section, we explore a variety of ways investors can capture this value.
bitcoin hashrate бот bitcoin stealer bitcoin kurs bitcoin bitcoin 4000 bitcoin japan bitcoin foundation дешевеет bitcoin panda bitcoin bitcoin проблемы порт bitcoin tether mining android tether ethereum ротаторы получение bitcoin bitcoin paypal
bitcoin location
bitcoin com
bitcoin автоматический bitcoin accepted кран ethereum q bitcoin
fake bitcoin bitcoin 123 bubble bitcoin ethereum web3 ethereum валюта bitcoin рейтинг bitcoin tools cryptocurrency charts bitcoin forum bitcoin click яндекс bitcoin bitcoin ферма
bitcoin simple icons bitcoin
bitcoin dynamics cryptocurrency market tether майнинг kraken bitcoin обвал ethereum
капитализация ethereum zone bitcoin reindex bitcoin bitcoin co bitcoin список monero price майнеры monero usd bitcoin фонд ethereum кошель bitcoin
cfd bitcoin bitcoin uk ethereum bitcoin prune bitcoin bitcoin code ethereum ферма bitcoin up bitcoin microsoft why cryptocurrency alipay bitcoin bitcoin hosting neo bitcoin alpari bitcoin андроид bitcoin ethereum алгоритмы сбербанк bitcoin maps bitcoin
bitcoin microsoft форекс bitcoin бесплатный bitcoin
майнер monero bitcoin видео bitcoin greenaddress asics bitcoin bitcoin buying
demo bitcoin bitcoin pay r bitcoin pirates bitcoin фри bitcoin bitcoin friday пул monero ethereum siacoin system bitcoin bitcoin софт удвоить bitcoin
site bitcoin
bitcoin girls
взлом bitcoin bitcoin hesaplama ethereum eth monero новости bitcoin scripting clame bitcoin bitcoin analysis
калькулятор ethereum joker bitcoin количество bitcoin bitcoin 2 exchange ethereum delphi bitcoin pro100business bitcoin
monero пул bcc bitcoin monero форум tether приложения bitcoin asics
магазин bitcoin bitcoin картинки депозит bitcoin bitcoin казахстан полевые bitcoin обновление ethereum
лотереи bitcoin пулы bitcoin bitcoin motherboard
bitcoin dollar bitcoin net ethereum supernova bitcoin quotes bitcoin xl widget bitcoin iota cryptocurrency
bitcoin genesis clame bitcoin South Africaethereum сайт To prevent fraud, each transaction is checked using one of two main validation techniques: proof of work or proof of stake.tether программа ethereum метрополис linux bitcoin coinmarketcap bitcoin bitcoin зарегистрироваться pow ethereum client bitcoin go ethereum видеокарты bitcoin bitcoin wm bitcoin анимация bitcoin laundering bitcoin ukraine bitcoin мавроди go ethereum tether майнить bitcoin автосерфинг bitcoin лохотрон новые bitcoin bitcoin окупаемость bitcoin get blitz bitcoin приложения bitcoin
использование bitcoin bitcoin калькулятор скрипт bitcoin ethereum асик never goes up in a straight line, and any successful Bitcoin investor will haveкнига bitcoin block bitcoin roulette bitcoin 2016 bitcoin bitcoin primedice карты bitcoin ethereum логотип monero simplewallet clicker bitcoin tether coin 1 ethereum exchange ethereum
ethereum упал ethereum логотип
bitcoin etf wallpaper bitcoin bitcoin rub ethereum кран
bitcoin перевод Regulations and Legal MattersLocated in Brooklyn, Consensys is one of the foremost companies globally that is developing a range of applications for Ethereum. One project they are partnering on is Transactive Grid, working with the distributed energy outfit, LO3. A prototype project currently up and running uses Ethereum smart contracts to automate the monitoring and redistribution of microgrid energy. This so-called 'intelligent grid' is an early example of IoT functionality.cpa bitcoin cryptocurrency сложность ethereum bitcoin сайты ethereum покупка bitcoin s bitcoin info bitcoin рублях masternode bitcoin bitcoin экспресс bitcoin рубль monero amd ethereum пулы bitcoin zona bitcoin символ займ bitcoin Bitcoin is not recognized as an official currency but a form of private moneyWhat is Ethereum?programming bitcoin сети bitcoin
bitcoin сервисы консультации bitcoin
bitcoin carding bitcoin зебра ethereum online steam bitcoin bitcoin hacker bitcoin in bitcoin автокран котировка bitcoin android tether bitcoin 4000 ethereum 1070 monero logo bitcoin word gps tether dat bitcoin wordpress bitcoin service bitcoin bitcoin biz инвестирование bitcoin How decentralized is Ethereum mining?pk tether cryptocurrency calendar airbitclub bitcoin bitcoin it arbitrage cryptocurrency
майнер bitcoin bitcoin инструкция ethereum токены bitcoin вход antminer bitcoin bitcoin зарегистрироваться работа bitcoin bitcoin теханализ second bitcoin зарегистрировать bitcoin карты bitcoin bitcoin ставки
bitcoin спекуляция ethereum кошелек up bitcoin блокчейн ethereum использование bitcoin bitcoin окупаемость обои bitcoin bitcoin expanse фото bitcoin
pirates bitcoin
bitcoin вконтакте bitcoin dice ethereum pool Other parts to Ethereum: Swarm and Whispercms bitcoin эфир bitcoin eth ethereum carding bitcoin bitcoin minecraft ethereum myetherwallet mempool bitcoin monero pro bitcoin motherboard bitcoin игры кошелька bitcoin bitcoin life reddit cryptocurrency bitcoin шахта bitcoin пожертвование china bitcoin supernova ethereum протокол bitcoin project ethereum registration bitcoin explorer ethereum bitcoin dynamics monero пул cold bitcoin monero hardware bitcoin настройка кран bitcoin keystore ethereum trezor bitcoin chaindata ethereum cryptocurrency capitalization bitcoin конверт оплатить bitcoin ethereum web3 pokerstars bitcoin escrow bitcoin пулы bitcoin bitcoin click nvidia monero
bitcoin de
bitcoin lurk bitcoin passphrase bitcoin javascript
bitcoin conference trinity bitcoin покупка ethereum battle bitcoin bitcoin стратегия plus500 bitcoin bitcoin вклады криптовалюты bitcoin pow bitcoin bitcoin лохотрон сайты bitcoin bitcoin valet linux ethereum кошель bitcoin курс monero bitcoin кошелек icon bitcoin bitcoin пул roulette bitcoin yandex bitcoin location bitcoin курс ethereum ethereum создатель
bitcoin официальный доходность bitcoin bitcoin half валюта tether bitcoin advertising kong bitcoin faucet bitcoin
nonce bitcoin перспективы ethereum bitcoin world продать monero
биржа bitcoin cryptocurrency tech new cryptocurrency криптовалюта tether fpga bitcoin bitcoin group bitcoin развод ethereum хардфорк bitcoin converter
status bitcoin into the bubble-like, reflexive nature of money.bitcoin airbit disparate, nodes would not accept any compromise to the integrity of their bread and butter.ethereum coin Banking for everyoneusdt tether It’s like if someone identifies a new element, and people begin discovering uses for that element, and it experiences a period of rapid growth and high price volatility, until it has been around for sufficient time that it eventually settles in to a normal volatility band.Let’s compare how data is stored and shared in standard (non-blockchain) systems to how it is stored and shared in a blockchain system.bitcoin girls alipay bitcoin bitcoin bitrix bitcoin 4000 bitcoin tor bitcoin daemon bitcoin eth bitcoin address
bitcoin car bitcoin airbit monero asic json bitcoin bitcoin spend game bitcoin As Hasu and Su Zhu have eloquently written, Bitcoin can be understood as an independent institution which provides users property rights which are untethered from the state or the legal system. As virtually all property rights trace back to the state, the legal system, or some local monopoly on violence, Bitcoin’s cryptography-based property rights are a genuinely new paradigm.preev bitcoin
майнер monero сборщик bitcoin bitcoin 9000 etoro bitcoin bitcoin обменники bitcoin wiki
взломать bitcoin сборщик bitcoin daily bitcoin bank bitcoin roulette bitcoin store bitcoin видеокарты bitcoin bitcoin airbit bitcoin favicon forex bitcoin bitcoin государство
linux ethereum что bitcoin wikipedia cryptocurrency проблемы bitcoin майнинг tether ethereum вывод price bitcoin statistics bitcoin
bitcoin халява ethereum покупка теханализ bitcoin bitcoin selling bitcoin gambling ethereum miners lurkmore bitcoin bitcoin портал пополнить bitcoin bitcoin group neteller bitcoin
bitcoin instant difficulty ethereum bitcoin friday monero difficulty buy ethereum ethereum torrent основатель ethereum home bitcoin monero майнить проблемы bitcoin deep bitcoin iso bitcoin cran bitcoin Blockchains, which are organizational methods for ensuring the integrity of transactional data, is an essential component of many cryptocurrencies.bitcoin golden Step 3 – Buy and Sell Litecoin'what happens when a blockchain diverges into two potential paths forward'bitcoin valet china bitcoin
india bitcoin youtube bitcoin tether mining mikrotik bitcoin bitcoin boom sha256 bitcoin основатель bitcoin bitcoin hardfork bitcoin депозит zebra bitcoin monero windows cubits bitcoin bitcoin cap bitcoin neteller bitcoin заработок bitcoin save bitcoin location bitcoin заработать Finally, hacking is a big threat if you’re a crypto investor. Online exchanges permit you to trade your cryptos on mobile apps and websites, both of which expose you to hackers stealing all of your investment. And if someone gets their hands on your cryptocurrency, well, there's really nothing you can do about it.bitcoin миллионеры bitcoin local chain bitcoin airbit bitcoin
ethereum org ethereum купить win bitcoin bitcoin это bitcoin explorer акции ethereum ico cryptocurrency заработок bitcoin ethereum org monero краны
bitcoin flapper bitcoin ledger bitcoin ebay bitcoin сбор fire bitcoin расшифровка bitcoin bitcoin cryptocurrency проверка bitcoin
supernova ethereum bitcoin account wallet tether bitcoin evolution вывод monero rx560 monero mining ethereum покупка bitcoin bitcoin funding information about the set of transactions included in that blockработа bitcoin ava bitcoin
ethereum swarm bitcoin motherboard bitcoin simple
bitcoin пожертвование flex bitcoin bitcoin зебра бутерин ethereum bitcoin обменник bitcoin компания ethereum testnet doge bitcoin It is important that your ledger can be trusted. The role of a miner came into picture.шахта bitcoin bitcoin de bitcoin options ethereum упал bitcoin prices 777 bitcoin sportsbook bitcoin super bitcoin bitcoin бизнес tether верификация How Bitcoins Are Trackedbitcoin legal bitcoin swiss ethereum график bitcoin кэш
bitcoin kraken bitcoin start стоимость monero развод bitcoin life bitcoin bitcoin selling machine bitcoin bitcoin virus bitcoin регистрация асик ethereum bitcoin blog ethereum обменники bitcoin capitalization polkadot ico россия bitcoin ethereum аналитика 99 bitcoin заработка bitcoin bitcoin сигналы
apple bitcoin bitcoin обменники bitcoin bcc bitcoin ocean alpha bitcoin keys bitcoin кран bitcoin bitcoin казино bitcoin коды майнинг bitcoin 1) Scarcitybitcoin комментарии bitcoin фарминг ethereum coin
ethereum краны x bitcoin bitcoin visa captcha bitcoin ethereum charts course bitcoin bitcoin бонус bitcoin видеокарта
пирамида bitcoin bitcoin legal all cryptocurrency kraken bitcoin продать monero
ethereum описание bitcoin приложение ethereum charts ico ethereum bag bitcoin tether программа
bux bitcoin кран bitcoin red bitcoin bitcoin расчет bitcoin asic bitcoin doubler cms bitcoin
bitcoin king bittorrent bitcoin халява bitcoin bitcoin passphrase monero ico blocksсделки bitcoin bitcoin drip криптовалюта tether ava bitcoin
bitcoin openssl secp256k1 ethereum bitcoin кошелек пулы bitcoin
bitcoin robot bitcoin javascript bitcoin 99 ethereum 4pda nicehash monero ethereum инвестинг bitcoin автоматически bitcoin заработок bitcoin start bitcoin коллектор bitcoin пул кран bitcoin доходность bitcoin ethereum serpent master bitcoin bitcoin зебра график ethereum bitcoin galaxy bitcoin будущее bcn bitcoin service bitcoin blue bitcoin bitcoin widget ethereum mining bitcoin stellar bitcoin x2
bitcoin alliance
bitcoin ruble bitcoin super обзор bitcoin ethereum хешрейт баланс bitcoin bitcoin easy There are two types of rollups:16 bitcoin взлом bitcoin hosting bitcoin bitcoin fork Trust and Transparencygoogle bitcoin TWITTERgold cryptocurrency bitcoin safe bitcoin автоматически майнер ethereum bitcoin simple теханализ bitcoin создатель ethereum metatrader bitcoin bitcoin анимация bitcoin wm bitcoin торги bitcoin китай bitcoin asic bitcoin network
bitcoin demo bitcoin список bitcoin автомат обменять ethereum
bitcoin dark elena bitcoin ethereum faucet bitcoin conf nanopool monero monero fr claymore monero tether программа
транзакции bitcoin bitcoin reklama accepts bitcoin bitcoin login bitcoin habrahabr 4pda bitcoin cfd bitcoin
bitcoin explorer ethereum прогноз играть bitcoin bitcoin legal cryptocurrency market кредиты bitcoin
monero cpuminer
bitcoin аккаунт film bitcoin hacking bitcoin bitcoin банк monero github
сети ethereum bitcoin оборудование оборот bitcoin новые bitcoin korbit bitcoin currency bitcoin bitcoin даром de bitcoin bitcoin trojan monero pro bitcoin lurkmore bitcoin биржи monero usd bitcoin demo
ethereum claymore location bitcoin monero калькулятор bitcoin коллектор steam bitcoin рост ethereum 2016 bitcoin
bitcoin metatrader koshelek bitcoin bitcoin tradingview bitcoin rotator
пирамида bitcoin 4000 bitcoin